Skip to main content
Paper Buddy

Medical manuscript writing

How to Write a Case Report Discussion: Example, Causality and Conclusion

The Discussion of a case report is not a second summary of the case. It explains what readers can learn from the case and how far that interpretation can go. CARE checklist item 11 asks for the strengths and limitations of your approach, the relevant literature, the rationale for your conclusions and the main take-away lessons. This guide turns those four elements into paragraphs and shows how to fix a common error: treating improvement after an intervention as proof of its effect.

By the Paper Buddy team · Sources checked:

This guide covers the Discussion of a single-patient case report. The examples and worksheets are educational suggestions created by Paper Buddy, not an official CARE translation or submission form. Adapt them to verified clinical records and your journal’s instructions.

In shortOne lesson → comparison with the literature → possible and alternative explanations → specific strengths and limitations → a one-paragraph conclusion without references. A temporal sequence alone does not establish causation.

Four questions a case report Discussion answers: CARE 11a–11d

CARE checklist item 11 asks the Discussion to cover the strengths and limitations of your approach to the case (11a), the relevant medical literature (11b), the rationale for your conclusions (11c) and the primary take-away lessons in a one-paragraph conclusion without references (11d). The CARE explanation and elaboration paper includes an assessment of cause and effect in 11c and asks authors to discuss limitations transparently, including that results from a single case may not apply to patients in general.[1][3]

On small screens, scroll the table horizontally to compare every column.

Four roles in a case report Discussion · the order is an editorial suggestion, not set by CARE
Role (CARE)Question to answerCommon problem
Lesson and literature (11b)What can readers learn from this case, and how does it agree or differ with verified reports and studies?Summarizing the literature at review length, or claiming a “first report” without a documented search.
Rationale and causality (11c)How do you explain the observed course, and why are other explanations less likely or impossible to exclude?Treating improvement after an intervention as proof of its effect.
Strengths and limitations (11a)What did the management and records of this case establish, and what could they not establish?Ending with “this is a single case” without saying what remains uncertain.
Conclusion and lesson (11d)What is the one thing readers should take into practice or further research?Adding references or new facts to the conclusion, or turning one case into a general recommendation.

A worked revision: “improved after treatment” is not proof

This is a fictional teaching case. An adult patient started Drug A on Day 0 and developed a rash on Day 10. Drug A was stopped on Day 12, and topical treatment was started on the same day. The rash resolved by Day 20. The patient was not rechallenged, and no tests were performed to exclude an intercurrent infection. Drug A is not a real drug, and this is not a real patient record or publication.

  • First sentence: state the observation with its timing. Write “resolved within 8 days of discontinuation” rather than “disappeared,” using the timing and criteria in the records. Define the reference point for relative days (Day 0) in the case description.
  • Second sentence: state what limits causal interpretation. Connect concurrent treatment, rechallenge status and tests not performed to the interpretation. Do not add unverified mechanisms or numbers.
  • Final sentence: bound the lesson. A lesson to “consider” a diagnosis differs from a recommendation to change prescribing. Stay within what a single case can support.

A core Discussion paragraph

Wording to improve

Drug A is widely prescribed, and several adverse reactions have been described. In our patient, a rash developed after Drug A was started and disappeared after it was stopped, which proves that Drug A caused the rash. To our knowledge, this is the first reported case. Clinicians should avoid Drug A in patients with similar characteristics.

Revision or template

In this patient, a rash appeared 10 days after Drug A was started and resolved within 8 days of its discontinuation. This sequence is consistent with a drug-associated reaction but does not establish causation: topical treatment was started on the same day Drug A was stopped, the patient was not rechallenged, and no tests were performed to exclude an intercurrent infection. In a search of [databases] up to [date] using [search terms], we identified [number] reports of rash associated with Drug A, in which [onset timing and course in the verified reports]. This case suggests that a drug-associated reaction should be considered when a rash develops during treatment with Drug A; as a single observation, it does not support changes in prescribing practice.

The revision keeps the temporal sequence (onset on Day 10, resolution within 8 days of discontinuation) and links concurrent topical treatment, the absence of rechallenge and the unassessed infection to the limits of causal interpretation. The “first report” claim is removed; the scope and results of the literature search actually performed are left in brackets. If you have not verified sources for the brackets, leave the sentence out. This paragraph is not a complete Discussion or a formal causality assessment.

Assessing causality: examine each alternative explanation

The CARE explanation and elaboration paper notes that case reports can detect signals of causal relations but usually cannot exclude the possibility of a chance association. Longitudinal findings may strengthen the case for a causal link, and the paper suggests reporting other clinical management the patient received and its potential impact. Its example for item 11c considers other causes one by one and states which explanations cannot be ruled out.[3]

  • Check field-specific requirements. For adverse drug reactions and similar reports, check whether the journal’s instructions or field-specific guidance require a separate causality assessment. Do not describe an assessment you did not perform.

On small screens, scroll the table horizontally to compare every column.

Alternative explanation worksheet · complete only from verified records
Explanation to examineRecords to check in the manuscriptExample wording
Effect of the intervention or exposureTiming of start, stop and dose changes; rechallenge statusconsistent with …; temporally associated with …
Concurrent treatment or other careOther drugs or procedures in the same period; care by other servicescannot be separated from the effect of …
Natural course of the conditionPrevious course; activity of the underlying conditionspontaneous resolution cannot be excluded
Other causes or chanceTests performed and tests not performed… was not assessed; a chance association cannot be excluded

Compare the literature with your case instead of summarizing it

Rather than summarizing every related paper, choose reports that can be compared with the key features of your case. To call a case the “first report” or “rare,” record the databases, search terms and search date, and make the claim only within that scope. Fill the worksheet below from sources you have actually read.

The CARE explanation and elaboration paper advises discussing the key features of the case and what was learned succinctly, and comparing the results in the case with results from clinical trials and case reports. Mechanisms and diagnostic challenges belong in the Discussion when they help explain the observations; support any recommendation for further research with published references.[3]

On small screens, scroll the table horizontally to compare every column.

Literature comparison notes · complete from verified sources
CheckThis caseVerified report or study
Patient characteristics and setting[De-identified characteristics and care setting][Source location and conditions]
Presentation and diagnostic route[Symptom timing, tests and differential diagnosis][Same route? What differs?]
Intervention and timing[Type, start, changes and reasons][Reported intervention and timing]
Course and outcome[Follow-up period and assessment method][Reported outcome and follow-up]
Basis for interpretation[Statement supported by this case record][Scope supported by the source and differences]

Strengths and limitations: report what the management and records establish

CARE checklist item 11a asks for the strengths and limitations of your approach to the case. The CARE explanation and elaboration paper asks authors to discuss limitations transparently, including that results from a single case may not apply to patients in general. Report only strengths that the records support.[1][3]

  • Examples of strengths Repeated assessments, photographic or video documentation, or adequate follow-up that can be seen in the case description.
  • Examples of limitations No rechallenge or comparison, tests not performed, short follow-up, incomplete records, or missing information about care by other services.
  • Consequence for interpretation Connect each limitation to the conclusion it weakens. Example: because topical treatment started on the same day, resolution cannot be attributed to stopping the drug alone.

Write the conclusion as one paragraph without references

Some journals use a separate Conclusion section, while others expect the final paragraph of the Discussion to serve as the conclusion; check the journal’s instructions. The principles are the same either way.

CARE checklist item 11d asks for the primary take-away lessons in a one-paragraph conclusion without references. The official CARE writing guidance likewise describes the conclusion as usually one paragraph that offers the most important findings from the case without references.[1][2]

  • Include The answer to the reason for reporting stated in the Introduction, and one lesson readers can take away.
  • Leave out References, findings or numbers not given earlier, recommendations beyond a single case, and phrases such as “proved effective.”

A conclusion paragraph for the same fictional case

Revision or template

When a rash develops during treatment with Drug A, a drug-associated reaction should be included in the differential diagnosis. In this patient, the rash resolved after Drug A was discontinued, although concurrent topical treatment means that the resolution cannot be attributed to discontinuation alone.

It adds no references or new numbers, and it carries the limitation discussed earlier (topical treatment started on the same day) into the strength of the conclusion.

A Discussion scaffold to adapt to your case

Replace brackets with verified information. Remove unsupported sentences or leave the issue explicitly unresolved. Do not add words such as “first,” “proven” or “must” merely to make the prose sound stronger.

This case illustrates [one lesson linked to the reason for reporting].
Compared with [verified reports or studies], our patient differed in [presentation, timing, management or outcome], which [what the comparison shows or leaves unresolved].
We considered [alternative explanation]; it is [less likely because of documented finding] / [cannot be excluded because assessment was not performed].
A strength of this report is [documented strength]; however, [specific limitation] limits [interpretation], and findings from a single patient may not apply to other patients.

[Conclusion: the primary take-away lesson in one paragraph, without references.]

Review the Discussion with the case description and abstract

Prepare a Word or PDF manuscript containing the case presentation and Discussion, then select “Start my manuscript review.” Choose Case Report as the study type, sign in, open the manuscript and run Health Check. In the Discussion, look first at conclusions stronger than the clinical course, statements absent from the case description and lessons that do not match the abstract.

Request to adapt: “Separate sentences in the Discussion that repeat the clinical course, causal wording stronger than the records support, alternative explanations not examined, and references or new facts in the conclusion. Identify the supporting locations in the case description. Do not invent facts, numbers or citations. List anything the manuscript cannot establish as a question for the authors.”

  • Before revising Reread each flagged sentence against the case record and check that the problem is present. Do not add tests, events or patient statements absent from the records.
  • After revising Reconcile timing and lessons across the abstract, case description, timeline and Discussion. AI review does not determine causation, confirm publication consent or replace co-author review.

Frequently asked questions

How long should a case report Discussion be?

CARE does not set a length. Word and reference limits for case reports vary by journal, so check the instructions first. The tighter the limit, the less literature summary and the more focus on the lesson, comparison, limitations and conclusion.

Can I call my case the “first report”?

Only if you have recorded the databases, search terms and date, and you state that scope. Adding “to our knowledge” does not replace a documented search; without one, it is safer to leave the claim out. Rarity alone does not determine whether a case is worth reporting.

Can I cite references in the conclusion?

CARE checklist item 11d asks for the take-away lessons in a one-paragraph conclusion without references. Compare with the literature in the body of the Discussion and use the conclusion for what this case teaches. Follow the journal’s instructions if it requires a different format.

Is the Discussion of a conference case presentation the same?

The logic is the same—lesson, comparison, limitations and take-away—but conference abstracts and slides are much shorter. Follow the meeting’s length and format, and keep the lesson and the limits of interpretation in one or two sentences. A case report abstract template is in the abstract guide.

Sources and how we checked them

CARE checklist item 11 (Discussion), the official CARE writing guidance and the CARE explanation and elaboration paper (Riley et al., 2017) were checked on November 18, 2026. The paragraph structure, examples and worksheets are educational suggestions created by Paper Buddy, not official forms.

  1. CARE: case report checklist (2013)
  2. CARE: writing a case report
  3. Riley DS, et al. CARE guidelines for case reports: explanation and elaboration document. J Clin Epidemiol. 2017;89:218–235