Skip to main content
Paper Buddy

Manuscript revision · response letters

Response to Reviewers: Letter Template and English Examples

A response to reviewers connects each editor or reviewer comment with a direct answer, a supported reason and the actual manuscript change. Start with the decision letter and your revision records, then build the letter one comment at a time. This guide combines a structure, English templates and a practical check against the revised paper.

By the Paper Buddy team · Sources checked:

The Paper Buddy team created these teaching templates and fictional wording examples. They are not a journal’s official forms, completed responses or evidence that any analysis was performed. Replace brackets with verified facts and use past-tense claims only after the work and revision are complete. JAMA Network’s 2026 guidance does not permit AI-written author responses to reviewer or editor comments; write those responses yourself. JAMA Network (2026)

In shortOriginal comment → direct answer and reason → actual action → final manuscript location. Respond to every part of a comment, including requests you cannot meet or disagree with. Check the journal’s instructions before choosing the format.

1. Organize the letter before polishing the language

Read the editor’s decision, deadline and file requirements first. Make an inventory of the original comments and record which author will resolve each one. The order below is a useful working structure; follow a required journal template when one exists.

  1. Opening and overview: Identify the manuscript and summarize the most important verified changes. Keep the overview short enough that it does not replace the individual replies.
  2. Separate editor and reviewer sections: Use stable labels such as E1 and R1-1. Preserve the original comment, including multiple questions in the same paragraph, so that a difficult request does not disappear during summarizing.
  3. Answer, explain and show the action: State your position first, then the reason and what actually changed. Distinguish existing material from a new revision, and explain a decision to make no change.
  4. Location and closing: Give the section, page and lines in the named revised file. Add a short relevant excerpt where useful or required, while following the journal’s preference for long passages. End with a brief closing.

Source guidance: Noble (2017) · Taylor & Francis · JAMA Network (2026)

2. An English response-letter template

Copy this structure into a working document, then replace every instruction. The opening assumes you are submitting an actual revised manuscript; do not use it for a revision still in progress. The repeated block belongs to one comment, with separate answers for each request inside it.

Dear [Editor name],

Re: [Manuscript ID], "[Manuscript title]"

Thank you for the opportunity to revise our manuscript.
We submit the revised manuscript and our point-by-point response.
The main changes are [brief summary of verified changes].
[Explain how comments, responses and revised excerpts are distinguished.]

Editor — Comment E1
[Copy the complete original comment.]
Response: [Direct answer, reason and action actually taken.]
Location: [Revised file/version, section, page and lines.]
Revised text: "[Exact relevant excerpt, if requested or useful.]"

Reviewer 1 — Comment R1-1
[Copy the complete original comment. Address every question in it.]
Response: [Agree, partly agree or disagree; give a supported reason.]
Changes: [Actual revision, or explain why no change was made.]
Location: [Revised file/version, section, page and lines; if applicable.]

[Repeat for each editor and reviewer comment.]

Thank you for considering our revised manuscript.
[Corresponding author, on behalf of the authors]

Use labels, indentation or type styles that remain clear in print; do not rely on color alone. Verify the final page and line numbers after editing and pagination. Avoid an unverified blanket claim that every concern has been resolved.

3. English examples for six types of reviewer comment

These are alternative wording patterns, not a checklist of work that every revision must perform. Choose the pattern matching your real action. Keep the comment, response, exact change and supporting record together while adapting the language.

Agreeing and making a revision

Name the issue and the specific correction. A thank-you followed only by “corrected” leaves the reviewer searching for what changed.

We agree that the eligibility criteria needed clarification. We have specified [verified criterion] in the Methods (revised manuscript, page [X], lines [Y–Z]). The revised text reads: "[Exact revised sentence]."

Use “have specified” only when the criterion is verified and appears in the revised Methods. The quoted sentence must match the actual file, not a proposed edit.

Addressing part of a request

Separate the part you adopted from the part you did not. Explain the remaining request with a concrete scientific or data-related reason rather than treating “partly agree” as the answer.

We have added [supported detail] to [section] (page [X], lines [Y–Z]). We have not included [requested extension] because [specific, documented reason]. We have explained the resulting limitation in [location].

The final sentence is appropriate only if you added or clarified that limitation. If several questions remain, answer them individually; one partial response should not conceal an omitted point.

Disagreeing with a supported explanation

Identify the exact proposal you disagree with and explain why it does not fit the study or evidence. Keep the discussion about the work. A reader’s misunderstanding can still justify a clarification in the paper.

We respectfully disagree with [specific proposal] because [reason supported by the study design or a verified source]. To make the scope clear, we have revised [sentence or section] (page [X], lines [Y–Z]).

Replace the reason with evidence the authors have checked. If you made no manuscript change, say so explicitly instead of keeping the second sentence. Ask the editor to resolve conflicting requirements when necessary.

Requests for an additional analysis or experiment

First establish whether the work was performed, is feasible or cannot be done with the available records. These two examples describe different situations; do not combine them or turn a planned analysis into a completed result.

If the work was completed

We performed [specified analysis] using [actual data and method]. The result was [verified estimate and uncertainty], reported in [table or section]. We have updated the Methods and Results at [locations].

If the work cannot be performed

We cannot perform [requested analysis] because [specific limitation of the available data or design]. We have clarified [the scope of the conclusion] and explained this limitation in [section] (page [X], lines [Y–Z]).

For completed work, check methods, denominators, uncertainty, tables and interpretation together, even when the result is unhelpful to the original claim. For unavailable work, give the actual data or design constraint and a bounded conclusion. If time or scope needs discussion, contact the editor before the deadline rather than inventing a result.

Requests to add a reference

Find the requested paper in a bibliographic record and read the original before deciding whether it supports the proposed sentence. A real DOI does not establish that the source supports your claim.

We reviewed [complete, verified citation] and added it to support [specific claim] in [section] (page [X], lines [Y–Z]). We also revised the sentence to reflect [the relevant population, outcome or limitation in that source].

Do not manufacture a citation to fill the brackets. Record the relevant passage and check numbering after insertion. If the requested paper is irrelevant, explain why and what clarification you made instead; adding a citation is not automatic agreement with its interpretation.

Requests for English-language editing

Describe the passages and language issue you actually revised. A short before-and-after example can show the repair without claiming the entire manuscript is now error-free.

We have edited [specified sections] to clarify [the wording issue]. For example, "[Original wording]" now reads "[Revised wording]" (page [X], lines [Y–Z]). We checked the edited passage against [reference manuscript or source] to confirm that [the relevant meaning, conditions and values] were preserved.

Do not claim professional or native-speaker editing unless that service was used. Check that wording changes preserve scientific meaning, numbers and citation scope. Language editing does not authorize AI use that the target journal prohibits.

Source guidance: Noble (2017) · Taylor & Francis

4. Keep the revision cover letter distinct

A cover letter can identify the manuscript and revision round, summarize major changes and address requests directed to the editor. The point-by-point document carries the detailed replies; a cover letter does not replace it.

Name the submitted files and confirm only declarations you have actually checked with the authors. If you need an extension or have conflicting instructions, explain that to the editor through the journal’s specified channel.

English cover-letter example for a revised manuscript →

5. Avoid gaps between the reply and the paper

  • A missing sub-question: Compare the finished letter with the original reports, not only with a shortened task list. Assign a response to every request, including editorial requirements.
  • “Revised” without a location: Identify the revised file and the relevant section, page and lines. A comment number identifies the request, not the manuscript change.
  • A reply that outlived its edit: If an edit is changed or rejected, revise the reply too. Search the final file for the sentence quoted in the letter before submitting.
  • A personal rebuttal: Replace judgments about the reviewer with evidence and a clear scope statement. Put unresolved conflicts or process concerns to the editor separately.
  • An unfinished submission package: Check the deadline, clean and marked manuscript requirements, anonymous-review instructions and supplements. Recheck page and line numbers after the final export.

Source guidance: Taylor & Francis

6. Review replies and manuscript changes together in Paper Buddy

Where the journal permits AI assistance, Paper Buddy helps you review comment-level reply drafts with their linked manuscript revisions. It does not establish that an analysis was done, a reference is correct or the journal’s requirements have all been met. Begin with verified records and inspect the proposed text before adopting it.

Before starting

  • The original editor and reviewer comments in full. Copying only selected sentences can omit part of a request.
  • The manuscript used as the reference for your response, plus analyses and changes you have actually verified. Distinguish work not yet done from completed work.
  • The response language, required formats for the letter and revised manuscript, and the journal’s permitted AI uses. Do not use AI drafts for tasks the journal prohibits.

The review workflow

  1. Prepare the original comments and reference manuscript

    Start the reviewer-response task in Paper Buddy with the comments and the manuscript you will revise. Compare the separated comments with the original to ensure that editor requests or parts of multi-question comments have not been missed.

  2. Review the draft reply to each comment

    Check that the reply directly answers the reviewer’s question. When facts are missing, supply verified information before revising the reply. Never claim an experiment or analysis was completed if it was not, or add results you have not checked.

  3. Compare the linked manuscript revisions

    Read the original text and proposed revision before deciding whether to apply it. Check suggestions whose original location could not be identified reliably. If you change or reject a revision, check that the reply still matches the actual manuscript.

  4. Compare the response letter and final manuscript together

    Verify that every description of a change matches the final manuscript, then download both documents. Keep unresolved facts or remaining review items clearly marked as draft work. Verify submission page and line numbers against the final file.

A request to adapt only where AI assistance is permitted

Example: a reviewer asks you to explain the eligibility criteria more clearly.

Help me respond to the request to clarify the eligibility criteria. Suggest a reply and a manuscript revision using the criteria currently stated in Methods. Ask me separately about any facts that cannot be confirmed from the manuscript.

7. Check the final letter against the final manuscript

Keep a small record for each comment. The table below is an author-created working aid, not an official reporting standard or an automated verdict. Resolve blanks before describing the letter as ready to submit.

  • Does every original comment have a corresponding reply?
  • Does each reply clearly state agreement or disagreement, the reason and the actual action?
  • Do claims about new analyses or experiments match work actually performed?
  • Are the changes described in the replies present in the final manuscript?
  • Have you resolved unfinished markers, author questions, outdated replies and document locations?

On small screens, scroll the table horizontally.

7. Check the final letter against the final manuscript
RecordWhat to verifyWhere to record it
Comment and decisionOriginal request, direct answer and any unanswered sub-questionE1 / R1-1 and the response paragraph
Action and evidenceActual edit, completed analysis or documented reason for no changeFinal text, analysis output or verified source passage
Location and versionQuoted text and page/line numbers agree with the submitted fileRevised file name/version, section, page and lines

Frequently asked questions

Can I disagree with a reviewer?

Yes. Answer the actual request and give a reason supported by the study or evidence. State what changed or that no change was made. A polite explanation and a clear limitation are more useful than a personal rebuttal.

Can AI write a response for a JAMA Network journal?

JAMA Network’s August 2026 guidance does not permit AI-written author responses to reviewer or editor comments. Write these yourself. For other journals, check the specific task’s permitted uses; disclosure does not make prohibited use acceptable.

Can I submit an AI draft immediately?

Where AI assistance is permitted, the authors still verify every comment, fact, citation and claimed revision against the final manuscript. Resolve placeholders and incomplete work, obtain coauthor checks and follow the submission instructions before sending.

Can I ask a language editor or service to polish the response?

You can seek language advice within the journal’s and institution’s rules, while retaining author control of the argument and facts. Check confidentiality and any disclosure requirements before sharing an unpublished manuscript. Paper Buddy is a tool for reviewing drafts and revisions, not an author-response outsourcing service.

Sources and how we checked them

Sources checked November 3, 2026. The structure, templates, six example cases and record table are Paper Buddy’s teaching material. Publisher advice can differ on the amount of revised text to quote; follow the target journal’s instructions.

  1. Noble WS. Ten simple rules for writing a response to reviewers. PLoS Comput Biol. 2017;13(10):e1005730
  2. Taylor & Francis Author Services: How to respond to reviewer comments
  3. JAMA Network: Updated Guidance for Author Use of AI in Medical Publication (2026)
  4. ICMJE: Use of AI by Authors