Three ways to check a manuscript against a reporting guideline
Self-check with the official checklist
Download the STROBE or CARE checklist and record where each item is reported. It costs nothing and you see every sub-item, but it takes time and depends on a careful reader.
A dedicated AI checker
Upload or paste a finished draft and receive item-level findings. Useful as a second reader shortly before submission. You move text between the checker and your manuscript, and coverage, design handling and data policies vary by tool.
A check inside the writing workspace
The check runs on the manuscript you are writing, so you can fix an item and check again in the same place. The trade-off is that a workspace check may review a narrower set of items than a dedicated checker.
A general chatbot can also be asked to review a manuscript against a checklist you provide. Its result depends on what you attach, whether it read the whole document, and how you phrase the request; see the example request in our STROBE guide.
Dedicated checkers at a glance
The table summarises what each tool says about itself on its public pages, checked on October 20, 2026. It is not a test of accuracy; none of these pages published validation figures that we could find.
| Tool | Guidelines relevant here | Study design | How you use it | Data statement |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AnswerThis | STROBE 2007, plus PRISMA 2020, CONSORT 2025 and COREQ checkers; no CARE checker listed | You choose the STROBE design variant | Upload a PDF with selectable text, TXT or Markdown, or paste text; item-by-item findings with quotations and locations; one free manuscript, with free rechecks of identical text against other guidelines | Text goes to its backend and OpenAI. The application retains a hash for rechecks, not a manuscript library; OpenAI retention rules still apply |
| PeerReviewAI | STROBE and CARE, as part of its peer review | Cohort, case-control or cross-sectional design detected automatically | Paid peer review ($49 as listed) with a per-item judgement of adequate, incomplete or missing; 5–15 minutes as stated | Its pricing page claims Anthropic Zero Data Retention, processing in memory and immediate disposal after review; not independently audited here |
| MedSci Skills (Aperivue) | Open-source skills covering many reporting guidelines and risk-of-bias tools, including STROBE and CARE 2013 | Uses the guideline you name, otherwise detects it from the study type | Runs inside your own AI coding agent (for example, Claude Code); items marked present, partial, missing or N/A | Processing and retention depend on the configured agent and provider. The project warns against entering identifiable patient data |
| Penelope.ai | 30+ submission checks for journals; encourages EQUATOR checklists | Not stated | Offered to journals using Manuscript Manager; checks Word files | Not reviewed here |
Prices, limits and supported guidelines are quoted from the vendors’ pages and may have changed. Check the current page before you rely on any detail.
Deep Review: general critique and reporting checks
Google’s October 14, 2026 launch describes checks of logic, mathematical statements and evidence. It does not specify item-by-item CARE or STROBE checks. Treat that scope as unconfirmed; this does not prove the capability is absent or establish comparative medical accuracy. Google announcement
The launch provides two document reviews weekly with PDF and plain-text input. Google says uploads are not used for model training or improvement and are stored for one year for display. Check institutional rules before uploading unpublished work, and compare findings with the official checklist. See also the AI tools comparison and our hands-on comparison on a clinical manuscript.
Checking inside the writing workspace: what Paper Buddy does
Paper Buddy is a writing workspace for clinical, dental and nursing researchers. Its Health Check runs on the manuscript you are drafting and reviews key CARE-based items for case reports and key STROBE-based items for observational studies, together with the consistency of statistical reporting and how claims connect to evidence.
- Scope: Health Check reviews selected key reporting items, not every item on the official checklist. A dedicated checker that covers the full checklist will see items Health Check does not.
- Results: each item is shown as met, missing, unclear, not evaluable or not applicable, with linked manuscript passages where the judgement rests on them, and you can continue a specific issue in Paper Chat.
- Design: for STROBE, Health Check identifies the observational design from how participants were selected and followed, and assesses the rows for that design. Authors confirm the applicable guideline and the design.
- Data: Paper Buddy does not use your manuscripts, research data or AI conversations to train AI models; content needed for AI features is sent to AI providers for processing. See the Privacy Policy.
- Language: manuscripts are written in English, while the interface and AI reactions can follow English, Korean or Japanese.
The advantage is workflow, not completeness: you check, revise and check again on the same manuscript, alongside drafting, citations and co-authors. If you need item-by-item coverage of the full checklist, combine Health Check with the official checklist or a dedicated checker.
Which approach fits your situation?
| Your situation | A reasonable choice |
|---|---|
| The draft is finished and you want a second reader on the full checklist | A dedicated checker that covers your guideline, then the official checklist for anything it flags |
| You are still writing and want to catch gaps while you revise | A check inside your writing workspace, plus the official checklist before submission |
| You cannot upload the manuscript to an external service | The official checklist as a self-check, or a tool your institution approves |
| Your journal requires a completed checklist with page numbers | The official or journal form, filled in from the final file, whichever tool you used |
What every approach leaves to you
- The design and the guideline. Confirm the actual design and the checklist version your journal names; automatic detection can be wrong.
- The evidence behind each finding. Read whether the quoted sentence really covers the whole item, including its sub-items.
- The difference between “not reported” and “not done”. Never add a procedure or number that did not happen just to satisfy an item.
- Patient data and consent. Remove identifiers before using any AI tool and check consent for publication separately; see the case report guide.
- Disclosure. Record which tools you used and how, and follow your journal’s AI disclosure policy; see the AI disclosure guide.
Frequently asked questions
Does Google Deep Review check CARE or STROBE?
Google’s October 14, 2026 launch describes logical, mathematical and evidence review, but does not specify item-by-item CARE or STROBE checks. That capability is unconfirmed in the public description, rather than proven absent. Compare its feedback with the official checklist; this guide does not establish comparative medical accuracy.
Is there a free STROBE checker?
The official STROBE checklists are free to download and use as a self-check. As of October 20, 2026, AnswerThis states that one manuscript is free and rechecking identical text against other guidelines is free. You can also give a general chatbot the checklist and your manuscript, if your institution allows that service.
Is there an AI tool that checks CARE for case reports?
As of October 20, 2026, PeerReviewAI states that CARE is checked for case reports in its paid peer review, and the open-source MedSci Skills package from Aperivue includes CARE 2013. Paper Buddy Health Check reviews key CARE-based items in case report manuscripts. We did not find a CARE checker on the AnswerThis reporting checklist page.
Does an AI checker certify that my manuscript complies with STROBE or CARE?
No. The tools themselves present results as drafts for author review, not certification. Reporting guidelines are about what the manuscript reports; the authors and the journal decide whether the reporting is adequate.
Is it safe to upload an unpublished manuscript to an AI checker?
Read each tool’s data statement before you upload: where the text is sent, whether it is stored, and whether it may be used for training. Remove identifiable patient information, and follow your institution’s rules and any co-author agreements on sharing unpublished work.
Sources and how we checked them
The Paper Buddy team checked the sources below on October 20, 2026. This is an explanation, not an official policy interpretation or a test of tool accuracy. Check current journal and vendor pages before submission or upload.
- AnswerThis — STROBE checklist checker
- AnswerThis — reporting checklist tools
- PeerReviewAI — STROBE checklist guide
- PeerReviewAI — CARE checklist guide
- PeerReviewAI — pricing
- Aperivue — MedSci Skills repository and documentation
- MedSci Skills — reporting guideline check documentation
- Penelope.ai — manuscript checks for journals
- Google Research — Analyzing technical documents with Deep Review (October 14, 2026)
- STROBE — official checklists
- CARE — 2013 checklist
- Paper Buddy — what Health Check covers and its limits