What the policies agree on
- AI is not an author. ICMJE says chatbots should not be listed as authors because they cannot be responsible for the accuracy, integrity and originality of the work. JAMA, Elsevier and BMJ say the same. ICMJE
- Authors are responsible. Humans are responsible for any submitted material produced with AI help, so review and edit AI output carefully; it can sound authoritative and still be incorrect, incomplete or biased.
- Check permission and disclosure separately. Writing, translation, research and responses to reviewers can have different rules. A disclosure does not make a prohibited use acceptable. The journal-specific requirements are compared below.
- AI is not a source. ICMJE does not accept AI-generated material as a primary source. Cite the original literature and check every reference yourself.
- Plagiarism and images are your responsibility. Authors must be able to state that the paper contains no plagiarism, including in text and images produced by AI.
Where the statement goes, by policy
The location and level of detail differ. This table summarises the policies as checked on October 20, 2026; your target journal’s instructions take precedence.
| Policy | Writing and editing help | AI used in the research | Details asked for |
|---|---|---|---|
| ICMJE | Acknowledgment section, and describe the use in the cover letter | Methods section, in enough detail to replicate the approach | For research use: the tool, version and prompts where applicable |
| JAMA Network | Acknowledgment section | Methods section, including dates, prompts and how prompts were revised | Tool name, version and extension numbers, manufacturer, dates of use, how AI was used and on which parts, and confirmation that the authors take responsibility |
| JACC | No disclosure required when AI is used solely to assist manuscript writing | Report AI used in conducting the research in the Methods | The writing exemption does not extend to research use |
| Elsevier | A separate declaration section at the end of the manuscript, just before the references | Methods section, described in a reproducible manner | The tool or service used and the reason for using it |
| BMJ | Contributorship section | A fuller description in the Methods section | Which AI technology was used, why, and for what task |
ICMJE offers recommendations and Elsevier publishes a publisher policy; individual journal instructions may differ. Check your target journal before using a statement from this table.
Not every journal requires disclosure of writing help: JACC
JACC does not require disclosure when AI is used solely to assist manuscript writing. AI used in conducting the research must still be reported in the Methods. Its Editor-in-Chief’s October 6, 2026 article explains an existing policy, rather than announcing a change, and stresses authors’ responsibility for every word. JACC Editor’s Page
Human medical writers and their funding must still be acknowledged. This account concerns JACC itself; do not assume that the same rule applies to every JACC-family journal. Answer any AI-use questions from the submission system or editor accurately. If you resubmit elsewhere, check the new journal’s permitted uses and disclosure requirements again.
JAMA: disclosure does not replace permission
JAMA’s August 2026 guidance does not permit AI-written responses to reviewer or editor comments, or AI drafts of Opinion articles, Letters to the Editor and online comments. Check this before following the reviewer-response workflow. JAMA’s table and guidance
It discourages AI-generated or AI-formatted references and advises using standard reference managers instead. Formatting verified bibliographic metadata with a reference manager differs from asking a generative model to invent or rewrite references. Verify every source; see our reference verification guide.
AI-created or manipulated clinical images, illustrations, video and audio are not permitted unless part of a fully disclosed formal research design or method. Research-data visualisation has separate conditions; check the current instructions.
Do grammar checks and translation need disclosure?
This is where the policies differ most, and it matters for authors who write in English as a second language.
- JAMA: its guidance does not apply to basic tools for checking grammar or spelling. Using AI to assist with content creation, revision or formatting must be reported.
- Elsevier: basic grammar, spelling and punctuation checks need no declaration, but substantive changes to sentence structure or the organisation of the text should be disclosed.
- ICMJE: AI spell-checking and grammar correction are generally viewed as acceptable, but the same passage says authors should disclose if and how AI was used. “Acceptable” is not the same as “exempt from disclosure”.
- BMJ: the author page does not state an exemption for grammar tools.
Translation and substantive rewriting are different from basic spelling checks. JAMA permits translation with disclosure in the Acknowledgment. For Opinion and Correspondence manuscripts, it permits grammar, spelling and translation tools only after humans have written the initial text; AI drafting of those manuscripts remains prohibited. JAMA guidance
Record the actual task and follow the target journal’s rule, including any writing-assistance exemption such as JACC’s. Check data policies and institutional rules before entering an unpublished manuscript into a public translation service.
Example statements to adapt
These examples are our own wording, not text required by any journal. Replace every bracket with what actually happened, and delete anything that does not apply.
Korean draft translated into English (Acknowledgment)
The authors wrote the initial draft in Korean. On [dates], they used [tool name, version and extension if applicable] ([manufacturer]) to translate [sections] into English and revise the wording. The authors checked the translation against the original meaning, reviewed all changes and accept responsibility for the accuracy and integrity of the manuscript.Use this only if humans actually wrote the Korean draft first. Specify the sections translated and describe any content-generation work separately.
Language editing (Acknowledgment)
During the preparation of this manuscript, the authors used [tool name, version] ([manufacturer]) between [dates] to improve the language and readability of [sections]. The authors reviewed and edited all suggestions and take full responsibility for the content of the publication.Drafting and revision support (Acknowledgment)
The authors used [tool name, version] ([manufacturer]) on [dates] to suggest revisions to [sections] and to check the manuscript against [reporting guideline] items. All suggestions were verified against the study data and cited sources, and the authors take responsibility for the accuracy and integrity of the content.For JAMA, include extension numbers where applicable, along with the tool, version, manufacturer, dates, tasks, affected portions and confirmation of author responsibility.
A separate declaration section, where required
This original example can be adapted for journals that request a declaration before the references. Check the required heading; it is not a quotation of Elsevier’s recommended wording. Elsevier policy
The authors used [tool name, version] to [task] in [sections] on [dates]. They checked the suggestions against [the original draft / study records / cited sources], edited the manuscript themselves and accept responsibility for its content.AI used in the research (Methods)
[Tool name, version] ([manufacturer]) was used on [dates] to [task, such as screening abstracts or extracting variables]. The prompts, including their sequence and revisions, are provided in [supplement]. Outputs were checked by [who] using [method].Cover letter
We used [tool name] for [purpose] during manuscript preparation, as described in the [Acknowledgment / Methods] section. No AI tool is listed as an author, and the authors take responsibility for the content.Ask co-authors about AI use in translation, literature work and other stages before stating that no AI was used. Using ordinary reference-manager functions alone does not mean generative AI was used.
What to record while you write
Disclosure is easier if you keep notes from the start instead of reconstructing them at submission.
Tool, version and maker
Write down the name of each AI tool, its version or model where shown, and the company that provides it.
Dates and tasks
Note when you used it and for what: translation, language editing, restructuring, literature search, checklist review, analysis or figures.
Sections affected
Record which parts of the manuscript the AI touched, so the statement can say “on what portions”, as JAMA asks.
How you verified it
Keep a short note of how you checked AI output against the data and the original sources. This is the responsibility every policy places on the authors.
Co-authors and the final submission
Collect co-authors’ records and check permitted tasks, disclosure locations, submission questions and supplements. Repeat the policy check if you resubmit to another journal.
If you used Paper Buddy
Name Paper Buddy as the tool and describe what you used it for, for example language and revision suggestions in Paper Chat, literature search, or Health Check review of reporting items. Paper Buddy sends AI requests to external AI providers; see the Privacy Policy for how content is processed. If your journal asks for the underlying model and version, contact us before you submit rather than guessing.
Before entering patient information into any AI tool, check your institution’s data rules, consent and de-identification. See also the case report guide for consent and de-identification checks.
Frequently asked questions
Does every medical journal require disclosure of AI writing help?
No. JACC does not require disclosure when AI is used solely to assist manuscript writing; AI used in the research must still be reported in the Methods. ICMJE recommends disclosure, and JAMA requires it for manuscript preparation beyond basic grammar or spelling checks. Follow the target journal’s current policy and answer submission questions accurately.
Do I need to disclose using AI to fix grammar?
It depends on the policy. JAMA and Elsevier exempt basic grammar and spelling checks. ICMJE allows such uses but still asks for disclosure, and BMJ does not state an exemption. Translation and substantive rewriting require a separate check of the journal’s rules; JACC exempts assistance used solely for manuscript writing.
What if I wrote a draft in Korean and used AI to translate it?
Record the original language, tool, dates, translated sections and how you checked the result. JAMA permits translation with disclosure in the Acknowledgment; its discussion of Opinion and Correspondence manuscripts specifies human-written initial text. Adapt the example below to the target journal’s location and requirements.
Can AI write my responses to reviewers?
Check the journal before drafting. JAMA Network’s August 2026 guidance does not permit AI use for authors’ responses to reviewer or editor comments. Adding a disclosure does not make a prohibited use acceptable.
Can I list ChatGPT or another AI tool as an author?
No. ICMJE, JAMA, Elsevier and BMJ all say AI tools cannot be authors, because they cannot take responsibility for the accuracy, integrity and originality of the work.
Where does the AI disclosure go?
Under ICMJE, describe how you used AI in the cover letter and in the manuscript: writing assistance in the Acknowledgment, and use for data collection, analysis or figure generation in the Methods. Elsevier asks for a separate declaration section just before the references, and BMJ asks for it in the contributorship section. Use the location your journal specifies.
Can I cite ChatGPT as a source?
ICMJE states that referencing AI-generated material as the primary source is not acceptable. Cite the original sources, and check that each reference exists and supports the statement it is attached to.
Can I use AI-generated images or figures?
ICMJE makes authors responsible for ensuring there is no plagiarism, including in images produced by AI, and asks for AI used in figure generation to be described in the Methods. JAMA’s 2026 guidance does not permit clinical images or illustrations created or manipulated by AI unless they are part of a fully disclosed research design or method. Check your journal before using any AI-generated image.
What happens if I do not disclose AI use?
ICMJE states that nondisclosure of AI use may require corrective action and may be construed as misconduct in some circumstances. BMJ states that content may be rejected or changed after publication if AI use was inadequately declared.
Sources and how we checked them
The Paper Buddy team checked the sources below on October 20, 2026. This is an explanation, not an official policy interpretation or a test of tool accuracy. Check current journal and vendor pages before submission or upload.
- ICMJE — Recommendations, updated January 2026 (PDF), Sections II.A.3, IV.A.3 and V
- ICMJE — AI use by authors
- Flanagin A, Perlis RH, Bibbins-Domingo K. Updated Guidance for Author Use of AI in Medical Publication. JAMA. 2026;336(11):926–928
- Reporting Use of AI in Research and Scholarly Publication — JAMA Network Guidance. JAMA. 2024;331(13):1096–1098
- JAMA — Instructions for Authors: Use of AI in Publication and Research
- Krumholz HM. AI in Medical Writing: Why JACC Does Not Require Disclosure. JACC. October 6, 2026
- Elsevier — Generative AI policies for journals
- BMJ Author Hub — AI use