1. Choose a journal whose readers need your research
Start with the fit between your research question and the journal’s readership. Read its Aims and Scope, then look at recent articles to see whether it publishes work addressing similar questions or using relevant methods.
Check the article types it accepts as well. A journal may publish original research but not case reports, or accept only certain kinds of review. Confirming scope and article type before formatting can save you from preparing a submission the journal does not consider. [1]
Check indexing separately from the impact factor
If an institution or funder requires a particular index, search the journal title or ISSN in Clarivate’s Master Journal List and check its current collection. For a requirement described as ‘SCI’ or ‘SCIE’, confirm the institution’s precise definition and the relevant coverage requirements. [2]
A Journal Impact Factor does not by itself establish that a journal is indexed in SCIE. Clarivate expanded the Journal Impact Factor to include ESCI and AHCI journals starting with the 2023 Journal Citation Reports release. [3]
Check costs at this stage too: which submission, publication or optional open-access charges apply, and when they become payable. ICMJE recommends making required processing and publication charges clear before authors submit. [4]
2. Turn the journal’s instructions into a preparation list
As you read the author instructions, record the files and changes you need.
| Item | What to prepare |
|---|---|
| Article type and length | Accepted category and manuscript and abstract word limits |
| Abstract and keywords | Structured abstract requirements, headings and keyword rules |
| Manuscript files | Accepted file formats and whether the title page must be separate |
| Tables and figures | Number, file format, resolution and separate-upload requirements |
| References | Citation style, reference format and complete bibliographic details |
| Review model | Whether an anonymized manuscript is required and what to remove |
| Additional documents | Cover letter, declarations and reporting checklists where requested |
For double-anonymous review, you may need a title page containing author details and a separate anonymized manuscript. Check whether tables, figures and supplementary materials must be uploaded separately. The actual file set depends on the journal and its review model. [1]
Keep the instructions’ URL and the date you checked them with your list. This also gives coauthors a common reference when reviewing the final submission.
3. Prepare the declarations and checklists your study needs
Submission information can extend beyond the manuscript itself to authorship, ethics, funding and competing interests. Prepare the applicable items from the actual research records.
- Author names, order, affiliations and corresponding author contact details
- Every author’s approval of the final manuscript and its submission
- Funding and competing interests
- Ethics approval or exemption and any required consent
- Registration details and data availability statements where applicable
- Earlier dissemination, preprints and related manuscripts
Use the journal’s forms or submission fields when provided. ICMJE describes information on author approval, competing interests and related publications to include in the submission letter or forms. [5]
Choose reporting guidelines by study design
In health research, common examples include CONSORT for randomized trials, STROBE for observational studies, PRISMA for systematic reviews and CARE for case reports. Check the relevant guideline and any applicable extension; submit a completed checklist if the journal requests one. [6]
For each checklist item, record where the information actually appears in your manuscript. If it is missing, determine whether reporting is incomplete or the item does not apply to your study.
Distinguish preprints from simultaneous journal submission
Do not submit the same manuscript to multiple journals at the same time. If the work has appeared as a preprint or conference abstract, check the target journal’s policy and disclose the relevant details. Do not hide earlier dissemination or use an unchecked statement that the work has never appeared anywhere. [7]
4. Explain the contribution and journal fit in your cover letter
A cover letter helps the editor understand the manuscript’s main contribution and its fit with the journal. Build it around these questions:
- What manuscript title and article type are you submitting?
- What question did you investigate, and how?
- What is the main finding and contribution?
- Why does it matter to this journal’s readers?
- What declarations or additional explanations does the journal require?
Explain the connection between the contribution and the readership rather than copying the abstract. Instead of calling the study ‘highly innovative’, describe the gap it addresses and the information it adds. Follow the journal’s own requirements for the letter and how to submit it. [8]
English examples for original research, case reports and revisions to the same journal →
5. Check the journal’s AI disclosure requirements
If you used AI to edit English or draft the cover letter, keep a record of what the tool did.
ICMJE’s recommendations for medical publishing call for disclosing AI-assisted technology at submission and describing its use in the cover letter and the appropriate part of the manuscript where applicable. AI tools cannot be authors; human authors remain responsible for accuracy and appropriate attribution. Check the target journal’s required disclosure scope and location. [9]
An AI disclosure example for the letter → Journal-specific AI permissions and disclosure locations →
6. Check the online details and final submission files
Start from the submission link on the journal’s official website. Journals use different platforms, including ScholarOne and Editorial Manager.
After uploading files, compare the entered title, abstract and author information with the final manuscript. Check automatically extracted information yourself. The ScholarOne guidance also describes reviewing author details, files and the assembled submission before completing the process. [10]
Use these questions for your last review:
- Are author names, order, affiliations and the corresponding author’s email correct?
- Is every uploaded file the final version?
- Do figures, tables, equations and special characters display correctly?
- Are supplementary files and required declarations included?
- If anonymous review applies, are the review files appropriately anonymized?
If the system provides a preview or assembled PDF, open it and inspect it. Keep the manuscript number and confirmation email, and check that the submission is complete in the system.
7. Respond to the editorial decision
Depending on the journal, submission may be followed by an initial check, editorial assessment, external review and revision requests. Not every manuscript proceeds to external review. [11]
| Decision or request | Next step |
|---|---|
| Technical or document correction | Identify the missing items and resubmit through the specified route |
| Revision | Prepare changes and a response to each editor and reviewer comment |
| Rejection | Review the reasons and reassess the manuscript and target journal |
| Acceptance | Check publishing agreements, proofs and any applicable charges |
For a revision, separate the comments and answer them one by one. Explain what changed and where it appears in the manuscript. If you cannot implement a request, explain the study’s scope and supporting reasons, and revise the limitations where needed.
Before submitting, check three things once more
Does the study fit the journal? Do the files and declarations match the research records? Does the cover letter explain the contribution accurately? Review these points with your coauthors before completing the submission.
Official sources
Existing submission sources were checked on October 19, 2026. The cover letter section was reorganized and linked to the dedicated guide on October 25. Recheck current journal instructions when submitting.
- Taylor & Francis article submission checklist
- Clarivate Master Journal List
- Clarivate announcement on extending the Journal Impact Factor
- ICMJE recommendations on fees
- ICMJE recommendations on sending the manuscript to the journal
- EQUATOR explanation of reporting guidelines
- ICMJE recommendations on overlapping publications and preprints
- Springer Nature cover letter guidance
- ICMJE recommendations on AI use by authors
- Taylor & Francis guide to submitting with ScholarOne Manuscripts
- Taylor & Francis explanation of peer review