Skip to main content
Paper Buddy

Medical manuscript writing

After a Journal Rejection: Resubmit, Transfer, Appeal or Go Elsewhere

A rejection does not end a paper; it decides the next step. Before you revise anything, read what the decision letter actually allows, sort the reviewer comments, and choose one route: resubmit to the same journal if invited, accept a transfer if one is offered, or submit to a new journal. An appeal is the right choice only rarely. This guide shows how to read the decision, when each route fits, how appeals and transfers work at major publishers and at Korean and Japanese journals, and what to check before the next submission.

By the Paper Buddy team · Sources checked:

This guide covers what to do after a journal declines a manuscript. Journal policies are summarized as dated examples; the decision letter and the journal’s current instructions decide what applies to your paper.

In shortRead what the letter allows → sort comments into fit, fixable, fundamental and factual errors → choose one route → revise with the reviews → adapt to the new journal and confirm that no other journal is considering the paper.

Read what the decision letter actually allows

A rejection letter usually tells you more than “no”. Check whether the paper was sent for external review, whether the editor leaves room for a resubmission, and whether a transfer to another journal is offered. Nature Portfolio’s peer-review policy, for example, separates papers rejected promptly without external review, papers rejected with an indication that further work might justify a resubmission, and outright rejections. The Korean Journal of Radiology similarly distinguishes “Reject: Resubmission allowed” from “Reject: No further consideration”.[5][11][7][9][8][17][14][19]

  • Note the deadlines. Appeals: within 30 days at BMJ, 1 month at Elsevier and the Korean Journal of Radiology, and two weeks at Endocrine Journal. An unused BMJ transfer draft is removed after 90 days.
  • Keep everything together. Keep the letter, all reviewer reports and the submitted files in one place. You will need them for the revision, a response document or an appeal.

On small screens, scroll the table horizontally to compare every column.

Common decisions that end consideration of a paper · wording varies by journal
DecisionWhat to look for in the letterWhat it usually leaves open
Rejected without external review (desk rejection)No reviewer reports; a reason such as scope, priority or article typeAnother journal. Elsevier does not consider appeals for manuscripts rejected outright by its editorial team.
Rejected after reviewReviewer reports and an editor’s summary, with no invitation to resubmitAnother journal after revising with the reports; an appeal only on narrow grounds. BMJ and Wiley advise against sending a revised version to the same journal.
Rejected, resubmission possibleAn explicit statement that a substantially revised or extended version would be consideredA new submission to the same journal with a response to the previous reviews. The Korean Journal of Radiology treats it as a new submission and expects substantial changes, often further research or data.
Rejected with a transfer offerA link or suggestion to a named journal, often from the same publisherA transfer, if you accept it; otherwise another journal of your choice. Transfers are optional.

Sort the comments before deciding

Wait a day before replying to anyone, then sort each comment by what it would take to address it. This sorting decides your next step more than the label on the decision does. The examples use the fictional reminder cohort from Paper Buddy’s Discussion and Results guides: 200 adults, 30-day attendance of 82/100 with a reminder and 70/100 without, not randomized and not adjusted.

On small screens, scroll the table horizontally to compare every column.

Sorting reviewer comments · a working aid by Paper Buddy, not an official classification
TypeExample from the reminder cohortWhat it means for the next step
Fit or priority“The topic is outside the journal’s scope” or “of limited interest to our readers”Revising will not change the decision at this journal. Choose a better-matched journal.
Fixable“Report the adjusted difference and its confidence interval” or “the flow of participants is unclear”Fix it before any resubmission. The next journal may ask the same.
Fundamental“A non-randomized comparison cannot show that reminders improved attendance”You cannot revise the design. Narrow the claim, state the limitation and choose a journal where the evidence fits.
Factual misreading“Attendance is reported only for the reminder group”, when Table 2 reports both groupsMake the point impossible to miss in the next version. Only if it was the main reason for the decision can it be a ground for appeal.

Four routes, and when each fits

Most rejected papers go to another journal. Resubmitting to the same journal, a transfer and an appeal each depend on what the journal allows and what the letter says. Do not pursue two routes at once: ICMJE says the same manuscript should not be submitted to more than one journal simultaneously, and BMJ and Elsevier do not allow an appeal and a transfer at the same time.[2][4][8][9][6][12][15][14]

On small screens, scroll the table horizontally to compare every column.

Routes after rejection · examples checked 19 November 2026
RouteWhen it fitsRules to check
Resubmit to the same journalOnly when the letter explicitly allows a resubmissionNature says a resubmission needs a point-by-point response and that a revised version after an outright rejection will be declined without further review. Clinical and Experimental Pediatrics says rejected manuscripts may not be resubmitted. Internal Medicine accepts resubmissions of rejected manuscripts, and Endocrine Journal asks for a cover letter with the previous manuscript ID and history plus a response letter.
Accept a transferWhen the suggested journal suits the paper and its readersThe offer comes from the journal or publisher. Check what moves with the paper, whether you must reformat and the receiving journal’s fees.
Submit to another journalFor problems of fit or priority, or after fixing what the reviews foundThe first journal must no longer be considering the paper. The KAMJE guideline also says not to submit to a journal only to obtain reviews before submitting elsewhere.
AppealWhen a factual error or a documented conflict of interest changed the decisionUsually one appeal, and its outcome is final. While it is pending, do not submit elsewhere.

Appeal only when an error changed the decision

ICMJE says journals should clearly state their appeals process. The policies below agree on the grounds: a factual or technical error, or a reviewer’s or editor’s conflict of interest or bias, that affected the decision. A difference of opinion about interest, novelty or fit is not a ground. The Korean Journal of Radiology accepts appeals by email within one month but says they are ineffective in most cases and discouraged.[1][9][8][10][6][11][14]

  • Keep it short and factual. Name the comment the decision relied on, show where the manuscript answers it and accept the criticisms that stand.
  • Ask your co-authors first. Elsevier asks the corresponding author to appeal with the agreement of all authors.
  • Know when to stop. If the appeal is declined, the decision is final. Move to another journal rather than arguing again.

On small screens, scroll the table horizontally to compare every column.

Appeal rules at selected journals and publishers · checked 19 November 2026
Journal or publisherGroundsDeadline and numberWhile the appeal is pending
ElsevierEvidence of technical errors, or that an editor or reviewer may have a conflict of interest or has been biased. Not a difference of opinion on interest, novelty or suitability. Not for manuscripts rejected outright without review.Within 1 month; one appeal per submission; the appeal decision is finalDo not submit elsewhere or start a transfer.
BMJA serious mistake, or reviewers’ errors of fact or evidence of bias. Editorial fit is unlikely to be reconsidered. The letter must address all of the reviewers’ and editors’ points.Within 30 days; multiple appeals are not accepted; the editor’s decision is finalYou can appeal or transfer, not both.
PLOS ONEA significant factual error, or objectivity compromised by a documented competing interest, where correcting it would change the decision.Decisions on appeals are finalThe manuscript remains under consideration and should not be submitted elsewhere.
NatureA specific technical or other point missed by the referees and editors; confined to the scientific case.In writing, not by telephoneThe manuscript cannot be submitted elsewhere.
Endocrine JournalNot specified beyond the right to appeal.Within two weeksDo not submit elsewhere until the new decision is made.

Example: rewriting an appeal letter

An appeal that criticizes the reviewers or repeats why the topic matters gives the editor nothing to reconsider. Point to the specific error, show the evidence in the manuscript and say what you would change.

Before and after: an appeal letter for the reminder cohort manuscript

Wording to improve

We strongly disagree with your decision. Reviewer 2 clearly did not read our manuscript carefully, and the other comments are minor and easy to fix. Our study addresses an important clinical problem and deserves publication in your journal. We kindly ask you to reconsider.

Revision or template

Re: Appeal of the decision on manuscript [ID], “[title]” Dear Dr [name], We ask you to reconsider the decision on our manuscript because the main reason given appears to rest on a factual error. Your letter cites Reviewer 2’s comment that attendance was reported only for the reminder group. The Results section and Table 2 report 30-day attendance for both groups: 82/100 in the reminder group and 70/100 in the comparison group ([page and lines]). We agree with the other reviewers that the study was not randomized and that the 12-percentage-point difference is unadjusted. If you are willing to reconsider, we would state these limitations in the Abstract and Discussion [and add an adjusted analysis, only if it can be done with the available data]. All authors agree with this appeal, and we will not submit the manuscript elsewhere while it is being considered.

A fictional example based on the reminder cohort used in Paper Buddy’s Discussion and Results guides. Fill the bracketed parts from your own manuscript and records, and promise only analyses that the data you have can support. Send it through the journal’s appeal route (an email address, form or submission system).

Re: Appeal of the decision on manuscript [ID], “[title]”
Dear Dr [editor’s name],
We ask you to reconsider the decision on our manuscript because [the specific factual error / the documented conflict of interest] affected the main reason for rejection given in your letter.
[Quote or summarize the comment the decision relied on.] [Show the evidence: the section, table or figure, with page and lines, or the documented conflict.]
[Acknowledge the remaining criticisms you accept, and state what you would change if the manuscript is reconsidered. Do not promise analyses or data you do not have.]
All authors agree with this appeal. We will not submit the manuscript to another journal or start a transfer while the appeal is being considered.

If a transfer is offered

A transfer moves your submission to another journal, usually from the same publisher, so you do not have to start from scratch. It is optional, and it does not guarantee acceptance. What moves with the paper differs by publisher, so read the offer before you accept it.[16][17][18][19][20]

  • Judge the fit, not only the convenience. A transfer saves resubmission work, but choose the receiving journal as carefully as any other.
  • Revise anyway. Use the reviews to improve the paper before the receiving journal sees it, even if the reviews travel with it.

On small screens, scroll the table horizontally to compare every column.

Transfer services compared · checked 19 November 2026
ServiceHow it startsWhat movesOther points
Springer Nature Transfer DeskThe editor recommends the manuscript; Springer Nature says it never transfers a manuscript without the author’s approval.According to its author page, previous reviewer reports are not transferred. Between Nature Portfolio journals, referee comments are transferred.You can revise before finalizing. It is free of charge, and a transfer does not guarantee publication.
Elsevier Article Transfer ServiceAn offer in the rejection email; you accept by clicking the link.Reviewer comments and identities move if the journal is configured to do so.Often no reformatting is needed. An open access journal may charge a fee on acceptance.
Wiley Refer and TransferFrom the editor in the decision letter, or from Wiley’s Transfer Desk Assistant a day later.The manuscript, all files and any reviewer reports.Completely optional. Revising first is encouraged but not required.
BMJ Article Transfer ServiceAuthor-led (an alternative journal chosen at submission) or editor-led.All files, editor notes and peer review comments.Revise and reformat for the new journal. There is no transfer fee; open access journals charge an APC on acceptance. Each BMJ journal decides independently.
Circulation Journal → Circulation ReportsThe editor suggests a transfer by email.Not detailed in the instructions.Authors reply whether they agree to the transfer.

Submitting to another journal

Before you submit elsewhere, make sure the first journal is no longer considering the paper: the decision is final, and no appeal or transfer is under way. Then treat the manuscript as a new submission, not as a copy with a new journal name.[2][3][1][4][13][21]

  • Revise with the reviews. The next journal may use the same reviewers or raise the same points. Fix what is fixable and narrow claims that the design cannot support.
  • Consider sharing the previous reviews. ICMJE says it is helpful to include the previous editors’ and reviewers’ comments with the authors’ responses, and that editors encourage it. PLOS Biology asks for a cover-letter note naming the previous journal and manuscript ID, and a “Prior Peer Review” file with the full reports and a point-by-point reply.
  • Disclose what you must. ICMJE asks for a full statement about all submissions and previous reports that might be regarded as redundant publication, and for disclosure of preprints. We found no policy requiring you to tell a different journal that the paper was rejected elsewhere; answer truthfully if the submission form asks.
  • Adapt to the new journal. Check the article type, word and reference limits, reference style, required checklists, declarations and cover letter. Search the files for the previous journal’s name.
  • Withdrawals follow journal rules. ICMJE says authors may consider a manuscript withdrawn after a good-faith request even without confirmation, but JKMS considers a manuscript withdrawn only after the editor-in-chief approves. Get confirmation where the journal requires it.

Final check before the next submission

Go through these points with the decision letter, the reviews and the revised files open.

  • Status Is the paper no longer under consideration anywhere, with no appeal or transfer pending?
  • Reviews Has every reviewer comment been addressed in the manuscript or deliberately set aside for a stated reason?
  • Claims Do the abstract and conclusion stay within what the design shows?
  • Fit with the new journal Do the article type, length, reference style and checklists match the new journal?
  • Traces of the old journal Unless you are sharing them on purpose, have you removed the previous journal’s name, manuscript ID and replies to its editor from the files and cover letter?
  • Author approval Have all authors approved the revised version and the choice of journal?

Frequently asked questions

Can I send a rejected manuscript to another journal right away?

Yes, once the first journal is no longer considering it, with no appeal pending and no transfer in progress. ICMJE and the KAMJE guideline do not allow simultaneous submission. It is usually worth revising with the reviews first.

Do I have to tell the new journal that the paper was rejected?

We found no policy requiring this for a different journal. ICMJE encourages including the previous reviews and your responses, and some journals have a file type for them. Overlapping submissions and preprints must be disclosed, and a resubmission to the same journal must identify the earlier manuscript.

Can I appeal a desk rejection?

Elsevier does not consider appeals for manuscripts rejected without review, and most policies exclude disagreements about interest, novelty or fit, which are the usual reasons for a desk rejection. Unless a clear factual error drove the decision, move to a better-matched journal.

Can I resubmit to the same journal after an outright rejection?

Usually not, unless the letter invites it. BMJ, Nature and Wiley advise against it, and Clinical and Experimental Pediatrics says rejected manuscripts may not be resubmitted. Some journals, such as Internal Medicine and Endocrine Journal, accept resubmissions of rejected manuscripts under set requirements, so read the letter and the instructions.

Sources and how we checked them

We checked the ICMJE Recommendations, the Korean Association of Medical Journal Editors (KAMJE) publication ethics guideline (4th edition, 2025), and the appeal, resubmission and transfer policies of the publishers and journals cited below on 19 November 2026. Policies change, so check the current instructions before you act.

  1. ICMJE: Responsibilities in the Submission and Peer-Review Process (appeals and withdrawal)
  2. ICMJE: Overlapping Publications
  3. ICMJE: Sending the Manuscript to the Journal (previous reviews)
  4. Korean Association of Medical Journal Editors: Good Publication Practice Guideline for Medical Journals, 4th edition (2025, in Korean)
  5. Nature Portfolio: peer review policy
  6. Nature: editorial criteria and processes (resubmission and appeals)
  7. Wiley: peer review guidance (options after rejection)
  8. BMJ: if your article is rejected (appeals)
  9. Elsevier: editorial decision appeals policy
  10. PLOS ONE: editorial and peer review process (appeals)
  11. Korean Journal of Radiology: instructions for authors (decisions and appeals)
  12. Clinical and Experimental Pediatrics: instructions for authors (revised 18 June 2026)
  13. Journal of Korean Medical Science: Instructions for authors (revised 8 September 2026)
  14. Endocrine Journal: instructions for authors (appeals and resubmission of rejected manuscripts)
  15. Internal Medicine (Japanese Society of Internal Medicine): instructions for authors
  16. Springer Nature: Transfer Desk
  17. Elsevier: Article Transfer Service
  18. Wiley: manuscript transfer (Refer and Transfer)
  19. BMJ: Article Transfer Service
  20. Circulation Journal: instructions for authors (1 October 2025)
  21. PLOS Biology: submission guidelines (prior peer review)