Consent, ethics review and de-identification are separate checks
ICMJE says patients have a right to privacy that should not be violated without informed consent, and that identifying information should not be published unless it is essential for scientific purposes and the patient gives written informed consent for publication. Whether an ethics committee must review a case report is a separate question, decided by national rules and your institution. Journals usually ask for both a consent statement and an ethics statement, so prepare each one on its own.[1][2]
On small screens, scroll the table horizontally to compare every column.
| Check | Question it answers | Who decides | What to keep |
|---|---|---|---|
| Consent for publication | Has the patient (or the right representative) agreed in writing to publication of this report, including images? | The patient or representative, on a form the journal accepts | The signed form, kept where the journal or local rules require |
| Ethics review decision | Does this report need IRB review, an exemption, or no review at all? | Your institution’s IRB or ethics committee, under national rules | The written approval, exemption or “not research” determination, with any reference number |
| De-identification | Have identifiers that the science does not need been removed from the text, images and files? | The authors, following journal and institutional standards | A record of what you removed or generalized, and why the remaining details are needed |
Consent for publication is not consent for treatment
Item 13 of the CARE checklist asks whether the patient gave informed consent and says to provide it if requested. A signature on a treatment or surgery consent form does not show that the patient agreed to the publication of the case, photographs or video. Use a form written for publication.
ICMJE adds that consent to publish identifiable information requires that the patient be shown the manuscript to be published, and that the patient be told whether the material might be available on the internet as well as in print. When consent has been obtained, the published article should say so.[2][1][3]
- What will be published The text, images, video or other material, and whether the patient has seen the final version. COPE’s 2016 guidance also asks the form to state that the patient will receive no financial benefit from publication.
- Where and how Print and online publication, free or subscription access, and possible future uses. COPE’s guidance lists these as items the form should cover.
- Limits of anonymity COPE’s guidance says the form should make clear that the journal cannot guarantee anonymity. Explain that someone may recognize the case even without a name.
- Withdrawal Under COPE’s guidance, the patient may revoke consent at any time before publication, but not after the report has been published.
- Who obtains consent COPE’s guidance says the person obtaining consent should have the authority to do so, for example the senior clinician responsible for the patient’s care or their delegate.
Whose form, who keeps it, and who signs when the patient cannot
Journals differ on which form they accept and who keeps the signed copy. ICMJE allows consent to be archived with the journal, the authors or both, as local regulations or laws dictate; COPE’s 2016 guidance says journals should not collect the signed forms themselves and that the original should be held by the treating institution. Check the target journal before the patient signs, so the patient does not have to sign twice.[1][3][4][5][6][7]
- Deceased patients COPE’s guidance says the consent requirement also applies to deceased persons. BMJ points to the next of kin, Elsevier to the legal representative, and the Japanese surgical societies’ guideline to the bereaved family.
- Minors A parent or guardian signs. BMJ also asks a child with sufficient understanding to sign.
- Adults who lack capacity Elsevier accepts a legal representative’s written consent, while BMJ says usually no one can consent on the patient’s behalf. The answer depends on the journal and local law.
- Patients who cannot be traced Some journals allow publication only if the report is sufficiently anonymized, but BMJ Case Reports and Elsevier do not accept anonymization in place of consent for a case report. Ask the editor before you write, not after.
On small screens, scroll the table horizontally to compare every column.
| Journal or publisher | Form and copy | When the patient cannot consent |
|---|---|---|
| BMJ Case Reports (BMJ) | BMJ asks authors to use its consent form, which the patient signs after reading the article. BMJ Case Reports requires a signed form for every case report about a living individual, without exception. | Deceased: BMJ asks authors to seek permission from the next of kin; BMJ Case Reports requires a document confirming exhaustive attempts to contact the family if they cannot be reached. Children: a parent or guardian consents, and a child with sufficient understanding also signs. Adults lacking capacity: usually no one can consent on their behalf, so the information must be anonymised or the report is not published. |
| Elsevier journals | Elsevier provides no standard form. Consent must be explicit, written and fully informed; the author keeps it and provides it only if asked. | Deceased: consent from the nominated legal representative. Lacking capacity: written consent from the legal representative. Case reports need consent whether or not the images are anonymized. |
| Journal of Korean Medical Science (JKMS) | Authors state in the case description whether consent for publication was obtained. Where privacy may be at issue, a second consent to publish the final version, including images, is required; the editor may ask for copies. | Not specified in the instructions. |
| Journal of the Japan Pediatric Society (日本小児科学会雑誌) | Case reports state, in principle, that consent was obtained from the patient or a substitute decision-maker. Highly identifiable information needs written consent after the patient is shown the relevant part of the manuscript, covering print and electronic publication. | Consent from a substitute decision-maker is accepted. The number of cases that triggers ethics committee approval follows the institution’s rules. |
Ethics review: is a case report research?
Regulations define research, and reporting one patient’s routine care often falls outside that definition. Many institutions still want to be asked, and many journals want you to state what was decided. The examples below show how Korea, Japan and the United States frame the question, and how case-count cutoffs differ between institutions.[8][9][10][11][12][13][14]
- Get the decision in writing. Whether your institution reviews, exempts or declines to review the report, keep the written decision and any reference number. The Journal of the Japan Pediatric Society asks authors to state a “no review needed” decision in both the cover letter and the text.
- Count your cases. Cutoffs differ: 3 or fewer (Wisconsin), 5 or fewer (Ajou University Hospital) and 9 or fewer (Japanese Society of Gastroenterology abstracts) in the examples in the table below. Above the cutoff, or when you analyze cases systematically, the work is likely to be treated as research.
- Not research does not mean no consent. An exemption or a “not research” decision is about ethics review. It does not replace consent for publication, and the journal may still require consent.
- Check off-label use separately. The Journal of the Japan Pediatric Society asks authors to state any ethics committee approval obtained, where needed, for care outside insurance coverage or off-label use. Check whether the treatment you report was itself reviewed by your institution.
On small screens, scroll the table horizontally to compare every column.
| Country | National rule | Institution or society example |
|---|---|---|
| Korea | Article 13 of the Bioethics and Safety Act enforcement rule lists research that may be exempted from institutional review: research that uses public information or does not collect or record personal identifiers and falls into listed types, including research using existing records or documents about participants. | Ajou University Hospital treats an individual case report of 5 or fewer patients, based only on retrospective review of treatment records with no added tests, procedures or data collection, as exempt, but asks researchers to submit an exemption request so the IRB can confirm it. |
| Japan | The guidance on the national ethical guidelines (revised 1 April 2024) says reporting individual cases at society meetings or in professional journals to share information with other clinicians (so-called case reports) may be judged not to be “research” under the guidelines, when it can be regarded as part of care rather than research. If the judgment is difficult, consulting an ethics committee is recommended. Amended guidelines take effect on 1 December 2026, and the guidance is to be revised. | The Japanese Society of Gastroenterology’s 2026 ethics form for abstract submission places non-research case reports of 9 or fewer cases in a category that needs no committee review, provided privacy law and the related guidance are followed. |
| United States | The Common Rule defines research as a systematic investigation designed to develop or contribute to generalizable knowledge (45 CFR 46.102(l)). Privacy is governed separately by HIPAA. | The University of Wisconsin–Madison says case reports of 3 or fewer individuals generally do not meet the definition of research and do not need IRB review, but notes that some journals require IRB documentation; authors can request a “not research” determination. |
Remove identifiers even when you have consent
ICMJE says nonessential identifying details should be omitted, consent should be obtained if there is any doubt that anonymity can be maintained, and masking the eye region in photographs is inadequate protection of anonymity. If you change details to protect the patient, the authors should assure that the changes do not distort the scientific meaning.
In the United States, HIPAA’s Safe Harbor method lists all elements of dates except the year, and full-face photographs, among the identifiers to remove. The Japanese surgical societies’ guideline sets similar rules for Japanese papers and presentations, for example allowing dates down to the year and month when the patient cannot be identified.[1][15][16][4]
- Use relative days. Writing “day 0, day 10” keeps the clinical sequence without calendar dates. Do not change the order or intervals of events.
- Check images and files. BMJ does not accept photographs with faces obscured by blurring or black bars over the eyes. Remove names, ID numbers and dates from images, and check the file metadata.
- Watch combinations. A rare diagnosis combined with age, region and timing can identify a patient without a name. ICMJE’s standard is to obtain consent whenever anonymity is in doubt.
How to word the consent and ethics statements
“Informed consent was obtained” does not say consent to what, from whom or for which images, so it invites questions from the editor. State the type of consent, who gave it, what it covers, and the actual ethics decision with its source. Write only what the documents show, and do not let an AI tool fill in an approval number or an exemption you have not received.
On small screens, scroll the table horizontally to compare every column.
| Situation | Example phrase |
|---|---|
| The patient consented | Written informed consent for publication of this case report and the accompanying images was obtained from the patient. |
| A minor | Written informed consent for publication was obtained from the patient’s parents, and the patient also signed the consent form. |
| A deceased patient | The patient died before this report was prepared. Written informed consent for publication was obtained from the patient’s next of kin ([relationship]). |
| Exempt or no review needed | The [institution] IRB determined that this case report did not require review ([reference number]). |
| Approved | This report was approved by the [institution] IRB (approval number [number]). |
Before and after: consent and ethics statements for the Drug A case
Wording to improve
Informed consent was obtained. Ethical approval was not required for this case report.Revision or template
Consent for publication: Written informed consent for publication of this case report and the photograph in Figure 1 was obtained from the patient on the journal’s consent form. The patient read the final manuscript before submission.
Ethics: The [institution] Institutional Review Board confirmed that this case report did not require review ([reference number]).A fictional example based on the Drug A case used in Paper Buddy’s case report guides. Bracketed parts must be copied from the actual IRB document; leave them out if no document was issued. Use the heading and position the journal specifies (for example, a Declarations section, the case description or the Methods).
Consent for publication: Written informed consent for publication of [this case report / the images in Figure X / the video] was obtained from [the patient / the patient’s parent or legal guardian / the patient’s next of kin or legal representative, because (reason the patient could not consent)] on [the journal’s / the institution’s] consent form. [The patient (or representative) read the final manuscript before submission.]
Ethics: [The (institution) IRB or ethics committee approved this report / confirmed that it was exempt / determined that it did not require review] ([reference number, if one was issued]). [Or the wording the journal specifies.]When to do each step
Ask for consent before you start writing in earnest. If the patient declines or the journal needs a different form, you will know before the work is done. Get the final confirmation on the version the patient will actually read.[3][16][17]
- Before writing Choose the target journal and download its consent form. Ask your IRB how case reports are handled and whether you need a written decision.
- Before entering data into any tool Check your institution’s rules on moving patient data. Consent for publication does not by itself permit sending the clinical record to an external AI service.
- Before submission Have the patient (or representative) read the final manuscript and images, then obtain the signature. If the manuscript changes substantially during revision, ask the journal whether the patient needs to see it again.
- At submission Upload the consent or confirm that you hold it, as the journal requires, and add the statements. Keep the original where the journal and local rules require.
- Conference presentations The Japanese surgical societies’ guideline also covers society presentations, and the Japanese Society of Psychiatry and Neurology’s sample consent form covers both presentations and journal articles. Check the society’s rules when you submit the abstract; one form that covers both the presentation and the later paper saves asking the patient twice.
Final check before submission
Go through these points with the signed form, the IRB document and the final files open.
- Type of consent Is it consent for publication, not only for treatment?
- Scope Does it cover every image, video and table you are submitting, and online publication?
- Signer Did the right person sign: the patient, a parent or guardian, or a legal representative or next of kin for a stated reason?
- Manuscript seen Did the patient read the final version, or does the form state what they saw?
- Ethics decision Does the manuscript state the decision actually received and its source, with no invented numbers?
- Identifiers Have names, initials, ID numbers, exact dates, facility names and identifying image details been removed or justified?
Frequently asked questions
Does a single case report need IRB approval?
Often not as research, but it depends on your institution. Japan’s guidance says a case report may be judged not to be research, Korea’s enforcement rule allows exemption from review for research that uses existing records without collecting or recording identifiers, and some US IRBs say reports of 3 or fewer patients are not research. Many institutions still want a written decision and many journals ask for one, so check with your IRB before you write.
Is the patient’s consent for treatment enough?
No. Consent to treatment or surgery does not cover publishing the case, images or video. Use a publication consent form, preferably the target journal’s, and let the patient read the manuscript.
What if the patient has died or cannot be contacted?
COPE’s guidance says the consent requirement also applies to deceased persons, and journals usually accept consent from the next of kin or legal representative. For patients who cannot be traced, some journals allow publication only if the report is sufficiently anonymized, but BMJ Case Reports requires consent for every case report about a living individual and Elsevier requires consent for case reports. Ask the target journal before you write.
Do I need consent for a conference presentation?
Check the society’s rules. The Japanese surgical societies’ guideline covers presentations as well as papers and requires consent from the patient (or the bereaved family or a representative, or a guardian for a child), or ethics committee approval, if the patient could still be identified after de-identification. A single form that covers both the presentation and the later paper saves asking again.
Sources and how we checked them
We checked the ICMJE Recommendations, the CARE checklist, COPE guidance, the US Common Rule and HIPAA de-identification guidance, Korea’s Bioethics and Safety Act enforcement rule, Japan’s ethical guidelines guidance and the institution, society and journal rules cited below on 19 November 2026. The rules differ by country and change over time, so recheck them before you submit.
- ICMJE: Protection of Research Participants (patient privacy and consent for publication)
- CARE: case report checklist (2013)
- COPE: Journals’ best practices for ensuring consent for publishing medical case reports (2016)
- BMJ: Patient consent and confidentiality
- Elsevier: Research ethics (patient consent)
- Journal of Korean Medical Science: Instructions for authors (revised 8 September 2026)
- Journal of the Japan Pediatric Society: submission rules (April 2022 edition, in Japanese)
- Korea: Enforcement Rule of the Bioethics and Safety Act, art. 13 (in force 3 December 2025, in Korean)
- Ajou University Hospital IRB: what requires review (in Korean)
- Japan: Guidance on the Ethical Guidelines for Life Science and Medical Research Involving Human Subjects (revised 1 April 2024, in Japanese)
- Japan: notice on the amended ethical guidelines (published 27 August 2026, in force 1 December 2026, in Japanese)
- Japanese Society of Gastroenterology: ethics form for abstract submission (2026, in Japanese)
- US: 45 CFR 46.102, definitions (Common Rule)
- University of Wisconsin–Madison IRB: case reports
- US HHS: guidance on de-identification under the HIPAA Privacy Rule
- Council of surgical societies in Japan (外科関連学会協議会): guideline on patient privacy in medical papers and society presentations, including case reports (partly revised 2019, in Japanese)
- Japanese Society of Psychiatry and Neurology: sample explanation and consent form for case reports (revised 19 November 2022, in Japanese)